kevins, interesting that your experience with snare drums and calf heads parallels mine - except that I have yet to try calf/calf on a real vintage drum. But your finding leaves me little hope of success in this regard, well, I can definitely live with calf top/plastic bottom...
tdennis, so, that kit is yet to be played. You are correct in that all are WFLs are flaking. However, I am now in the midst of doing some restore work on my drum. I have put all metal parts in vinegar to remove rust, and - lo and behold - I was actually able to remove the lugs from the shell without any further flaking occurring. I was very careful, but what paint is left, sticks... I have polished (by hand) the shell carefully, and it now looks quite nice.
The metal parts come out fine from the vinegar bath. I have also polished them, using a very mild polish for metals, including nickel. It's amazing how the rust comes off after a night in vinegar. Below are some pics of what I have done so far:
First, a before and after of the strainer.
[img]http://web.comhem.se/inventions/downloads/Strainer_before.jpg[/img]
[img]http://web.comhem.se/inventions/downloads/Strainer_after.jpg[/img]
Here is the butt-end.
[img]http://web.comhem.se/inventions/downloads/Butt_before2.jpg[/img]
[img]http://web.comhem.se/inventions/downloads/Butt_after.jpg[/img]
Finally, here is a pic of the interior with heads removed. It is quite clear from the picture that there is no significant colour difference between the re-ring and the inner ply, suggesting that the inner ply is not mahogany, but maple. Do you agree with me here?
[img]http://web.comhem.se/inventions/downloads/WFL_interior.jpg[/img]
I will post some more pics once I have cleaned and remounted all the hardware on the drum.
/Magnus