For playing live I prefer a rock solid, new pedal. My go to model is the TAMA Iron Cobra single pedal using the double chain drive. I like to use this with a Vintage Bomber beater.
I have a Slingerland Epic, a Ludwig Universal, and a 68 Pearl standard but they are more for show or playing the practice room. I tried to play a show with the vintage Pearl and the bottom plate came unscrewed in the middle of a tune- I can`t have that happening...