Referring to a late 50's Leedy catalog, I saw wood Shelly Manne snares in 4.5 and 5.5 inch depths. This was during the Slingerland era and are supposed to be similar to their own snares.
Anyone know which Slingerland snare it would be comparable to?
Thanks!

Hi oaklandrichie!

Choosing about 1960 for both snare drums, I would say that the Shelly Manne snare drum might be similar to the Gene Krupa snare drum. Of course the GK used a one-ply maple shell, with the SM having a 3-ply shell. Still the layout was similar, well, except that the SM was offered in a 4.5x14. The SM used a 3pt-style strainer, but with the brackets that pulled the snare wires out being integral and not separate like the GK Radio King.

Slingerland implemented enough small changes, though, to make the Slinger-Leedy and Slingerland snare drums a bit different from each other!

-Mark

Originally Posted by idrum4fun

Hi oaklandrichie!

Choosing about 1960 for both snare drums, I would say that the Shelly Manne snare drum might be similar to the Gene Krupa snare drum. Of course the GK used a one-ply maple shell, with the SM having a 3-ply shell. Still the layout was similar, well, except that the SM was offered in a 4.5x14. The SM used a 3pt-style strainer, but with the brackets that pulled the snare wires out being integral and not separate like the GK Radio King.

Slingerland implemented enough small changes, though, to make the Slinger-Leedy and Slingerland snare drums a bit different from each other!

-Mark

I agree with Mark. The '58-'61 "Gene Krupa" model would be the most comparable to the same era "Shelly Manne" snare although there are still several differences as Mark noted. The '58-'61 "Gene Krupa" model used the three point strainer with bridges, not the clamshell strainer, which was used on the "Super Gene Krupa" model.

A little off topic but Jeff Hamilton recently had an Instagram post displaying Shelly’s Mahogany Leedy kit that he had put new heads on. It’s beautiful. You might want to check that out.

Originally Posted by Multijd

A little off topic but Jeff Hamilton recently had an Instagram post displaying Shelly’s Mahogany Leedy kit that he had put new heads on. It’s beautiful. You might want to check that out.

Thanks for the heads up! I'll check it out!

-Mark

Thanks, Mark!
That's great info.
Multijd,
I will check out that video.

The only real differences between the Slingerland and Leedy snares during the SlingerLeedy era was the strainer and the lugs. Other than that, they both used the same 3 ply shells, tension rods, hoops, mufflers and badge grommets. The two brands had differing wrap and duco colors as well. I don't think they ever cataloged a solid maple shell Leedy snare.



In catalog 62 Leedy offered, in the catalog anyway, the Shelly Mann snare with either the Slingerland three point with no extension bridges or the Leedy Broadway strainer with had the built in bridges. The 4 1/2" got the Slingerland three point.


I believe the Zoomatic was introduced in catalog 63 so in '62, the higher end Slingerlands would still be suffering with the Clamshell strainer on the Gene Krupa models.

I have a red sparkle Leedy blue badge Shelley Manne snare from 1965. To my eyes (and ears) it's basically a Slingerland Hollywood Ace model with nicer lugs and a better (to me at least) strainer. Great sounding drum.

Originally Posted by Jay_M

I have a red sparkle Leedy blue badge Shelley Manne snare from 1965. To my eyes (and ears) it's basically a Slingerland Hollywood Ace model with nicer lugs and a better (to me at least) strainer. Great sounding drum.

Hi Jay!

Any chance of posting some pictures? I'm sure we'd all love to see your drum!

-Mark

Originally Posted by idrum4fun

Hi Jay!

Any chance of posting some pictures? I'm sure we'd all love to see your drum!

-Mark

Mark: Here goes! It came with some modern stick choppers on it. I found a Slingerland stick saver from 70s for batter; reso is just a random flanged hoop.